Sony Kills Blu-Ray Advantage with PS3 Pricing

When assessing the relative strength of HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray for high definition disc format war handicapping, I have always been quick to point out that DVD is the likely successor to DVD, as it is "good enough" for most consumers and addresses a larger installed base of non-HDTVs in addition to HDTV sets with decent anamorphic ("enhanced for widescreen TV") performance. But the other thing I have noted time and time again is that Sony’s Playstation 3 (PS3) was a potential trojan horse, bringing Blu-Ray playback to the masses. At E3 today, Sony announced the pricing and availability for the …

Sony Kills Blu-Ray Advantage with PS3 Pricing Read More

Half a Format War Arrives: HD-DVD is Here

HD-DVD was formally launched last week with a single, $499 Toshiba deck. HomeTheaterView has not had a chance to get in a review unit yet, but Evan Powell over at Projector Central bought a unit and gushes buckets about it. Part of his review is a primer on the difference between 1080i and 1080p at the source vs. how its delivered to the display; this type of arcane differentiation is what pushes normal people to choose formats based on even dubious specs. For now, there’s nothing concrete to compare HD-DVD to in the market. But there’s so little content for …

Half a Format War Arrives: HD-DVD is Here Read More

2005 In Review / CES 2006 Review, Pt. 4: Media Formats

Part IV of my post-CES scribbles; each of the next few posts includes a quick look back on 2005 trends and a quick discussion of products introduced at CES 2006. This installment: Media Formats In 2005… The warring HD disc camps (HD-DVD and Blu-Ray Disc) could not achieve compromise, but did not actually ship anything to the market, either. With nearly no support from content owners, SACD and DVD-Audio essentially died in 2005. At CES 2006… Toshiba hyped its first HD-DVD player at the modest price of only $499. In contrast, Pioneer announced a single Pioneer Elite Blu-Ray Disc player …

2005 In Review / CES 2006 Review, Pt. 4: Media Formats Read More

Format Wars II: Revenge of the DVD

Tekrati picked up my post last week on the death of VHS, and implied that I said that Blu-Ray and HD-DVD killed off VHS.  Nothing could be further from the truth!  I often question whether there’s any mass market demand for a high definition format in the first place (and before I get flamed, yes, there is strong enthusiast demand.  I certainly want to go beyond 480p).  But only 11% of households have an HDTV, and anamorphic ("enhanced for widescreen") DVD looks pretty darn good on those sets.  We’re also going into the format war without clear and massive support …

Format Wars II: Revenge of the DVD Read More

Format Wars: A Format Dies!

Yes, at long last, the industry is consolidating the number of media types for pre-recorded movies… unfortunately, it looks like both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD will be launched as is, without any compromise.  This really isn’t all that unexpected, given the jockeying back and forth lately: Blu-Ray announced that its media can be manufactured inexpensively (which was supposed to be a key HD-DVD advantage) and HD-DVD announced 45GB capacity versions (nearly matching Blu-Ray’s 50GB storage, which was supposed to be a key Blu-Ray advantage).  But the two formats are fundamentally different at a technical level.  For example, the laser reads a …

Format Wars: A Format Dies! Read More

The Sony PS3 and HD-DVD/Blu-Ray Reapprochment

There’s been a flurry of news over the past month about Blu-Ray and HD-DVD backers getting together to avoid a format war for the next generation of high definition discs.  I’ve avoided covering each step on the drama, so here’s a quick recap of the posturing between the two camps: "Hey, we’re new here at Sony, and going proprietary hasn’t worked out so well in the past few years. Let’s work this BD/HD-DVD thing out" "OK" "Um, we can’t," "No, really, we’re still trying," "Look! HD-DVD can do 45GB per disc, too!" "A single format doesn’t look likely – the …

The Sony PS3 and HD-DVD/Blu-Ray Reapprochment Read More

Product Review: LG LST3510A HDTV tuner/DVD player

New connectivity options often drive product design, and DVI/HDMI is no exception.  DVI and HDMI are interfaces that allow you to keep the signal in the digital domain throughout their journey, making hookup simpler, and providing a noticeably sharper picture when viewing digital content (such as DVD or HDTV) on digital displays (like plasma, LCD, DLP, or LCOS), as the signal is never converted back and forth to analog at all. I’ve already written about how computer-like interfaces open up the A/V cable market to new entrants, but every product in the A/V chain may need to change as well.  …

Product Review: LG LST3510A HDTV tuner/DVD player Read More

Something There Is That Doesn’t Love a Format War

It seems like everybody’s writing stories about the upcoming HD disc format war between HD-DVD and Blu-Ray (BD).  The technical specs are reasonably locked down, but everything else is up in the air – perfect fodder for journalism/rampant speculation.  Gizmodo had prematurely called HD-DVD the winner based on studio support (I called them on it here).  More recently, DVDFile.com posted a follow up of sorts – also trying to predict a winner based on the various studios and where they’re currently lined up on the issue. This is pretty hard to do because the studios are about evenly split, and …

Something There Is That Doesn’t Love a Format War Read More

This Disc Will Self Destruct. Interested?

Wired is reporting that Disney has given up on Flexplay’s EZ-D disposable DVD format.  The press had a field day getting environmental activists all riled up against the format, but that’s just a sidebar.  If consumers found disposable DVDs moderately convenient, then the used discs would end up in the landfill alongside the rest of our disposable society.  If the discs were a smash hit, then we’d end up with another color plastic recycling bin for media (which might not be a bad idea anyway.  I must throw away hundreds of discs a year, even after AOL stopped mailing them …

This Disc Will Self Destruct. Interested? Read More

Upsampling is the new progressive scan

I don’t know why this didn’t come out at CES, but Samsung is expanding their lineup of upsampling DVD players.  The key product feature is added 768p support, which is the native resolution for many plasma and projectors (the players will also do 480i for regular TVs, 480p for digital EDTVs, and 720p and 1080i for other HDTVs). This is great news if you have a recent model 768p TV with DVI or HDMI, but this is NOT HD. It’s merely moving the process of image manipulation from your TV over to your DVD player. Your HD TV has more …

Upsampling is the new progressive scan Read More